Mother rejects SLO County’s attempt to settle death case


County Counsel Rita Neal is claiming the family of a 60-year-old man who died at the San Luis Obispo County Jail accepted a nearly $42,000 settlement, while the family’s attorney is saying no such settlement occurred.

Amid allegations of neglect at the county jail, in 2017 Kevin Lee McLaughlin died of a heart attack. He told his jailers he needed to go to the hospital, but his request was denied. Less than an hour later he was found dead.

Dorothy McLaughlin, the decedent’s 85-year-old mother, filed a lawsuit against San Luis Obispo County in 2018, alleging negligence that resulted in death.

Recently, the county offered to settle the lawsuit for $41,850, and Dorothy McLaughlin, wanting to avoid the stress of a trial, accepted the offer subject to approval by the San Luis Obispo County Board of Supervisors, according to the settlement agreement.

However, on Oct. 22, before the supervisors voted on the proposed settlement, Dorothy McLaughlin’s attorney James McKiernan withdrew his client’s acceptance.

“Dorothy McLaughlin will continue on with this grueling court process to see that justice is served for her dead son and others in the county jail whose serious medical complaints are disregarded by jail medical personnel,” McKiernan said.

County Counsel Rita Neal

Following the Oct. 22 closed session, in which the settlement agreement was on the agenda, County Counsel Rita Neal said there had been no reportable action. However, later in the day, Neal retracted her earlier statement and said that during closed session the supervisors had voted to approve the settlement offer.

McKiernan, however, said he sent an email prior to the alleged vote rejecting the settlement offer.

“The county’s offer to settle the McLaughlin case was rejected by the plaintiffs before it was finally approved by the Board of Supervisors,” McKiernan said. “The McLaughlin jail death case has not been settled and will proceed to trial.”

McKiernan plans to produce state and federal reports of deficiencies in inmate medical care “in violation of both state and federal law,” McKiernan said.

At around 2:30 a.m. on April 15, 2017, McLaughlin complained of pain in his left shoulder, including numbness and tingling, and that it felt like an “elephant was sitting on his chest,” according to the coroner’s report.

“Dorothy McLaughlin’s son complained to jail staff of multiple classic heart attack symptoms (which are noted in his jail medical records) that otherwise would have required him to be rushed to an emergency room code red. But his jailers gave him an aspirin, sent him back to his jail cell where he died 30 minutes later,” McKiernan said.

Please, be respectful of others. Attack ideas, not users. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, and other uncivil comments will be removed. The comments posted represent the opinion of the writer and do not represent the views or policies of the website.

2 Comments about “Mother rejects SLO County’s attempt to settle death case”

  1. Justice.Seeker says:

    Oh John…. how could you say such things ?

    Why the SLO Chief of Police is such an honorable “truth teller” and Saint for her selfless actions/inactions to Protect & Serve our Children & Citizens, and our SLO County “Representatives” are so determined to “Do the Right thing” in All those important “choices” they have, and then there’s our District Attorney, Dan Dow, who…… um… ahh…..

    ….well I’m chokin up, when just trying to type some sarcastic remarks about him being even a little forthright. LOL


    Kind of a shame, we have to constantly endure such criminal behaviors from the people who are supposed to be trustworthy, honest, and good.

  2. honestjohn says:

    Given the years of evidence of county counsel mistruths and coverups, I have to put my trust in the McLaughlin’s and not Rita Neal. Justice in this county is a lost concept.

Comments are closed.